Mark Johnston’s four-year-old was winning at Headquarters for the fourth time, but in conceding a 3lb penalty for his victory in the Jockey Club Stakes earlier in the season and 12lb to Ascot winner Dashing Willoughby, he put up a fine performance.
That meant he ran keen and when push came to shove, Masar found disappointingly little and dropped away.
Communique was sent off an 11-1 shot and when Dashing Willoughby weakened, only Mirage Dancer looked a possible threat, but the northern raider proved a length and three-quarters too good.
Johnston said “We don’t really have tactics and any idea he has to lead is not true – he bowled along and it didn’t matter he wasn’t in front.
“He’s had a couple of goes in Group Ones and come up short, but on his day he’s that class – that’s two Group Twos now.
“He’ll get another shot at a Group One some time soon.”
He went on: “It was a last minute confirmation for the Ebor, but I doubt he will go there. We want to win a Group One with him.
“He is in one at Hoppegarten and another Group One in Germany. That would be the sort of stepping stone before having a go at another Group One in England.”
Teddy Grimthorpe, racing manager of Mirage Dancer’s owner, Khalid Abdullah, said: “He has run a good race, but he couldn’t find that turn of foot. Again he has been consistent considering where we were at Christmas. He is still rolling and hopefully will go on some more.
“I would certainly look at going back to Goodwood as he has won a few times there, so you would have to look at it. They didn’t go quite fast enough for him. He will get there one day in a race like this.”
Appleby said of the defeated favourite: “He was in as good a nick as we could have him. He was fit and well.
“I hate to use an excuse when a race doesn’t pan out for you, but they didn’t go much of a gallop and he was just unfortunately over-racing on the outside and it paid in the end.
“As usual we hope he comes out all right, then we will make a decision on what we do with him. There are no immediate decisions.
“On his bit of work last Wednesday, I had no excuses coming into today. He had ticked every box. The great thing about this game is that is levels you.
“With any of these horses coming off a lay-off, you want to get some confidence behind them and get their head back in front. That is what I was hoping to achieve today. Unfortunately it has not happened so we will have to regroup.”
Doyle added: “There was no pace on and he crawled round. From our draw we could get no cover and he just over-raced the whole way. He really felt fantastic and he floated to the post.”