Free Bets

Next Race Off

Home / Racing News / Are there horses who have failed to fulfil their potential at Closutton?

Are there horses who have failed to fulfil their potential at Closutton?

Are there horses who have failed to fulfil their potential at Closutton?

Sunday sees the highly anticipated return of the Grade 1 John Durkan Memorial Chase. The race has been dominated by Willie Mullins since 2013, with ten wins from the last 13 renewals, and with Mullins fielding nine of the 11 runners (and the potential for the other two not to turn up), it looks set to go to Closutton once more.

Some will argue this is the result of Mullins’ brilliance, as building up an army of horses with such elite talent is no mean feat, whereas others will argue it is a stain on the sport that devalues the nature of competition.

The issue with having such an embarrassment of riches is that it makes it nigh on impossible to keep them apart, and there will almost certainly be some who run in races that don’t suit them. Naturally, there will be horses way down the pecking order who, in other yards, could not only have been stars themselves but potentially gone on to even greater success under rules.

This list could go on forever, but here are three horses from Closutton who failed to reach their potential.

Ballyburn

One of the most recent examples is Ballyburn. For any yard, a four-time Grade 1 winner, including at the Cheltenham Festival, would be a huge success. But if Ballyburn had been elsewhere, I think he’d have been a Champion Hurdle horse.

By Flemensfirth out of an Old Vic mare from a family of three-milers, it’s no surprise that connections went chasing with Ballyburn and campaigned him as a three-miler. A dual bumper winner over two miles, he demonstrated a turn of foot in both contests despite racing keenly throughout.

Although he was beaten over two miles on his hurdling debut and won over 2m4f by 25 lengths next time out, I wasn’t surprised to see him win a Grade 1 over two miles as a novice, when he beat subsequent Supreme winner Slade Steel.

While he won the Baring Bingham over 2m5f, he was firmly on the bridle throughout and won commandingly. On that card, only the Champion Bumper first and second completed the final four furlongs of their race quicker than Ballyburn.

Even on his second start over fences, he was beaten seven lengths by one of the best two-mile chasers we could have seen in recent years, despite making an awful mistake at the last. The belief that he is slow and needs three miles is wildly inaccurate.

If Mullins didn’t have Lossiemouth for the Champion Hurdle, I have no doubt Ballyburn would’ve lined up and won it comfortably. He’s a deceptively keen-going horse who would’ve been electric over two miles in another yard.

Vauban

Vauban was incredibly unlucky to bump into State Man three times in his career, and perhaps even more unlucky that Rich Ricci unearthed Lossiemouth in 2023. With two more genuine top-class two-milers in the yard, it made logical sense to give Vauban a Flat campaign before he was sent off to Australia.

But if he had been in any other yard, could you imagine them selling a 160-rated hurdler who was a three-time juvenile Grade 1 winner with form figures of 2342 in open Grade 1 company? Anywhere else, a 160-rated hurdler would’ve been the yard’s flag-bearer.

I’ve no doubt we didn’t see the full potential of Vauban over hurdles. The only horses he finished behind over jumps were Pied Piper, State Man (more than once), Honeysuckle, Zanahiyr and Constitution Hill, three of them Champion Hurdle winners.

It’s a shame to see him struggling in handicaps in Australia. He’s still only an eight-year-old and could no doubt have had a fruitful hurdling career.

Nichols Canyon

Nichols Canyon was perhaps the best second string Willie Mullins has ever had. He won 12 of his 30 races but was eventually second fiddle to the likes of Faugheen and Annie Power, despite being the first horse to beat the former.

11 good footballers don’t necessarily make a great squad, just as one Grade 1 hurdler doesn’t make a great yard, but had Nichols Canyon been elsewhere, he could’ve achieved much more in his career.

From his juvenile hurdling days, he often shaped as if he’d stay further, particularly when third in the Triumph before staying on strongly at the line in 2m4f contests at Aintree and Punchestown. I suspect that when he beat Faugheen at Punchestown, connections deemed him sharp enough to be campaigned as a two-miler.

Faugheen was clearly not at his best that day, so it wasn’t surprising to see Nichols Canyon largely disappoint thereafter. That was until he won the Stayers’ Hurdle over three miles, and he backed that up by being beaten only a neck over the trip by reigning stayers’ champion Unowhatimeanharry.

Had he been campaigned as a stayer, or at least more over the intermediate trip from the off in open company, I suspect he’d have achieved even more throughout his career.