Free Bets

Next Race Off

Home / News / The 2026 John Durkan & the dubious cusp of history on which Willie Mullins stands

The 2026 John Durkan & the dubious cusp of history on which Willie Mullins stands

The 2026 John Durkan & the dubious cusp of history on which Willie Mullins stands

Willie Mullins is on the cusp of history this Sunday at Punchestown. However, this particular landmark would be a travesty for jumps racing.

Only once in the history of the sport has a Group or Grade 1 race involved the participation of just a single trainer that was not ultimately a walkover. Remarkably, although unsurprisingly, this passed by with relatively little fanfare just under two years ago, when old foes Fact To File and Gaelic Warrior met in a match race for the Ladbrokes Novice Chase at the Dublin Racing Festival due to three non-runners in the same contest.

If you exclude the 1980 Woodward Stakes at Belmont Park, in which Spectacular Bid was the only horse not to be scratched, and thus walked over, the above Leopardstown race is the only top level contest in the history of the sport to be the sole domain of one trainer. Then, it was Willie Mullins and now, of course, it is Willie Mullins who may do so again.

11 horses have been confirmed for the 2026 John Durkan Memorial Chase, a race with a rich recent history. Galopin Des Champs was twice defeated in the race on his return, as well as winning it once, while last year served up a stunning spectacle as Gaelic Warrior gamely repelled Fact To File having torn off miles in front. The rest were nowhere.

That is the issue at hand too: the rest may literally be nowhere on Sunday. Henry De Bromhead is the only other trainer currently represented. However, that may not be the case come declarations, as Koktail Divin also has options at Ascot and Haydock, which his trainer can reasonably suggest are more suitable, while The Big Westerner has the Betfair Chase as an option too. She also only recently returned from a long layoff.

Koktail Divin, Aintree
Koktail Divin is one of two Henry De Bromhead horses who could prevent a Willie Mullins benefit race.

As such, history beckons. Should De Bromhead consider the alternatives more suitable, Mullins need only declare three to turn a genuine Grade 1 into a Closutton open day. And facing up to it, many more than three look like heading to Punchestown. We could well be made to endure a farcical event in which nine Mullins runners race each other and nobody else.

This, readers, is bad for horse racing. Mullins’ power and celebrity makes some appeal around Cheltenham time when punters can make the bookies cower. But for one man to play monopoly over such an historic race is desperate.

We have been close to this situation at times. Gordon Elliott not only trained all three runners in the Grade 2 Florida Pearl Novice Chase at the same meeting two years ago, but the entire trio were owned by Gigginstown House Stud too. Mullins, likewise, had every runner in the 2022 New Year’s Day Chase at Tramore at Grade 3 level.

Mullins’ flat racing equivalent, Aidan O’Brien, nearly achieved this fickle feat in 2019 too, when scheduled to send out five of the six runners for the Futurity Trophy at Doncaster. The race did not take place due to waterlogging, with the extra irony that the only other declaration, Andrew Balding’s Kameko, won the rearranged race at Newcastle.

With respect to the 1981 Oaks d’Italia, in which Alduino Botti trained five of the six runners, that race does not possess much bearing on the present day, and even then, Botti still had to face one contender to that particular throne. If De Bromhead defers, Irish racing cannot lamely blame him, nor Messieurs Elliott, Meade, Connell or Cooper. This is a mess they must navigate, because Mullins has no incentive to.

Even if Koktail Divin and The Big Westerner are pitched in at the deep end, it will be papering over an ever-more-crunching chasm of competitive lack.